Aliens of the Elusive Kind

Jun 11th in Bizarre & Featured & UFO Phenomenon by

Right now, over at Cryptomundo, there’s a heated, extensive debate going on with respect to my views on Bigfoot. As I note at the site, in my personal view, the fact that Bigfoot is so darned elusive, and skilfully avoids capture, shooting or accidental death with an impressive 100 percent success rate, is something that  suggests – to me, anyway - Bigfoot is far more, or perhaps far less, than mere flesh-and-blood in nature and origin. The beast may well be, as I suspect, a Tulpa. Bigfoot, however, is not the only Fortean-related controversy that has the ability to outwit us on every conceivable occasion. It’s very much the same with Ufology.

Let’s take a look at the most famous UFO case of all (or, perhaps, infamous would be a far better word to use): Roswell. There are far more than a few reports in circulation, of those living local to where the event occurred back in the summer of 1947, having secretly collected some of the priceless debris from the desert-floor and hidden it away from prying eyes (from the dastardly government, in other words). The problem, however, is that precisely as is the case with the body of Bigfoot, the fantastic Roswell material consistently fails to surface – or, on the rare occasion it rarely does appear, analysis has always proved to be manifestly inconclusive.

Yep, despite all the claims of a “My grandfather saved some of the Roswell debris and it’s in his attic!”-variety, it never shows its face, proves it case, and elevates the notorious affair to undeniable fact.

Then there is the story of one Antonio Villas Boas, a Brazilian, who, late one night in 1957, claimed to have been kidnapped by aliens and then seduced by a vibrant space-babe who growled like a wild beast while the pair got it on. Hey, it doesn’t get much better than that, does it?

According to Villas Boas, after the close encounter of the erotic kind, his captors gave him a tour of the ship, during which he witnessed “three of the crew…sitting in swivel-chairs, grunting among themselves.” While they toiled over their screens and machines, said Villas Boas, he tried to steal a device that was sitting atop a table and that he described as “a square box with a glass lid on it, protecting a dial like the dial of an alarm clock.” It was not to be, however: “As quick as lightning one of the men jumped up and, pushing me aside, snatched it from me angrily, and went and put it back in its place.” Thwarted!

Moving on, many years ago, the UFO author and researcher Timothy Green Beckley was told by Fortean writer Gray Barker of a UFO encounter that occurred in Arko, Utah. The witness was a schoolboy, one Robert McCallister, who on the day at issue was roaming around his local woods when he stumbled upon a relatively small, circular-shaped device, hovering approximately six feet off the ground in an isolated clearing. Suddenly three, tall, unusual-looking men appeared – as did a silver-haired character, sitting atop a floating chair, no less – who invited McCallister for a tour of the compact flying saucer.

Rather intriguingly, the presumed alien seemed fascinated by a ball-point pen sticking out of McCallister’s pocket, which the boy subsequently offered the enigmatic figure as a gift. Seemingly very pleased – far too pleased, it might be argued – he, in turn, gave McCallister a present of a small, black, plastic-like tube. Then, McCallister was motioned to leave the craft and keep his distance – which he did – as it soon took to the skies and forever vanished. It was only later that McCallister realized the priceless artifact had mysteriously vanished from his pocket. Like so many others, he too was prevented at the very last moment from securing any hard evidence of the reality of the encounter.

It’s worth noting the highly insightful words of the author Jacques Vallee, who astutely recorded in his classic book, Passport to Magonia, that: “…centuries-old folklore is replete with tales of people who claimed to have visited the realm of the fairies and who tried to bring back with them a souvenir, only to be thwarted, in one form or another, from doing so at the last minute.”

From fairies to Bigfoot, and from Roswell to alien encounters, nothing much – it seems – has changed. In fact, scrap that word “much.” Zero has changed. Utterly elusive then, utterly elusive now. There is something deeply weird about our inability to secure hard evidence of a wide range of Fortean puzzles. Why that should be the case is a matter that demands our careful and deep attention.

 
  • Anonymous

    I think this is the most interesting article for a while because it covers ideas I share. Where does all the evidence go? In this case, the ‘evidence’ can be anything from a living creature to gun-camera footage to debris and a lot more.

    It’s seen as fairly ridiculous to attempt a unifying hypothesis that includes bigfoot, UFOs and bizarre contacts like Simonton and his pancakes. Sometimes however, I wonder if much of this involves an intelligence that is pretty much omniscient as far as we’re concerned?  Possibly an intelligence that could be responsible for many of these experiences as a way of measuring/assessing/testing an aspect of the human experience? The personal experience of the percipient could be some deliberate act analogous to putting a thermometer in the mouth of human consciousness. What’s actually being tested might not even be the percipient in particular, but the reaction of the society surrounding them and their consciousness. This isn’t meant in the same way Vallee suggested, there’s no intent to drive or change humanity…instead it could be simple observation and data-gathering towards some unknown end.

    A trigger-factor possibly appears to be stages in our technological development. For example, following Trinity tests, supersonic flight, early airships, aerial warfare etc we seem to have been swarmed by UFOs and bizarre contact experiences. To me, this could be interpreted as both a monitoring of our technology and our consciousness by something technological and beyond our current understanding.

    In this scenario, I’ve often wondered if the evidence has disappeared…not hidden by ‘tptb’ but *poof* into thin air..

    By this I mean what if  gun-camera footage captured a flying disc or sphere, but upon later viewing, revealed nothing? Imagine a crashed object being taken to an AFB only to find it isn’t there hours later? If Roswell was more than just a balloon, how would they react to finding the crashed disc from yesterday was now a collection of rubber and sticks? They’d have confirmation that ‘something’ was happening but the invisible, omniscient dog has definitely eaten the homework…no evidence at all!

    Disclaimer! I’m only speculating. :)

  • Anonymous

    I think this is the most interesting article for a while because it covers ideas I share. Where does all the evidence go? In this case, the ‘evidence’ can be anything from a living creature to gun-camera footage to debris and a lot more.

    It’s seen as fairly ridiculous to attempt a unifying hypothesis that includes bigfoot, UFOs and bizarre contacts like Simonton and his pancakes. Sometimes however, I wonder if much of this involves an intelligence that is pretty much omniscient as far as we’re concerned?  Possibly an intelligence that could be responsible for many of these experiences as a way of measuring/assessing/testing an aspect of the human experience? The personal experience of the percipient could be some deliberate act analogous to putting a thermometer in the mouth of human consciousness. What’s actually being tested might not even be the percipient in particular, but the reaction of the society surrounding them and their consciousness. This isn’t meant in the same way Vallee suggested, there’s no intent to drive or change humanity…instead it could be simple observation and data-gathering towards some unknown end.

    A trigger-factor possibly appears to be stages in our technological development. For example, following Trinity tests, supersonic flight, early airships, aerial warfare etc we seem to have been swarmed by UFOs and bizarre contact experiences. To me, this could be interpreted as both a monitoring of our technology and our consciousness by something technological and beyond our current understanding.

    In this scenario, I’ve often wondered if the evidence has disappeared…not hidden by ‘tptb’ but *poof* into thin air..

    By this I mean what if  gun-camera footage captured a flying disc or sphere, but upon later viewing, revealed nothing? Imagine a crashed object being taken to an AFB only to find it isn’t there hours later? If Roswell was more than just a balloon, how would they react to finding the crashed disc from yesterday was now a collection of rubber and sticks? They’d have confirmation that ‘something’ was happening but the invisible, omniscient dog has definitely eaten the homework…no evidence at all!

    Disclaimer! I’m only speculating. :)

  • Anonymous

    Yea, yea Nick. Great story as usual Nick. Lets push all of this aside and get to the true meat of the story. Where are these “vibrant space babes” that growl during sex and how does one contact them? Not that I’m looking for intergalactic sex or anything, it’s merely scientific? You know? Scientific curiosity?… Space babes that growl… Perhaps purr during sex… Yea, I’m not looking for that. It would be far too terrifying… If anyone knows where they’re abducting humans today, please share on this post so that all of us can… Stay away from that spot… Yes… I would never build my house in that spot…

  • Anonymous

    Yea, yea Nick. Great story as usual Nick. Lets push all of this aside and get to the true meat of the story. Where are these “vibrant space babes” that growl during sex and how does one contact them? Not that I’m looking for intergalactic sex or anything, it’s merely scientific? You know? Scientific curiosity?… Space babes that growl… Perhaps purr during sex… Yea, I’m not looking for that. It would be far too terrifying… If anyone knows where they’re abducting humans today, please share on this post so that all of us can… Stay away from that spot… Yes… I would never build my house in that spot…

  • Patrick Moore

    I think it’s clear why there is no real evidence – other than “people telling stories” – for these phenomena. The most likely explanation is that they are all misunderstanding, misidentification, delusion or hoax. Believers understand the problem, but are unwilling to abandon increasingly untenable hypotheses. That’s what results in more and more outlandish attempts to explain the total lack of *real* evidence. I mean really… Does anyone really believe that Bigfoot is an “interdimensional entity?” Some folks claim to believe it, but I find it hard to take them seriously. Perhaps some day some evidence for at least something along these lines will be found. But as the decades pass and still all we have are anecdotes of various degrees of unlikelihood, the chance gets closer and closer to zero.

  • Patrick Moore

    I think it’s clear why there is no real evidence – other than “people telling stories” – for these phenomena. The most likely explanation is that they are all misunderstanding, misidentification, delusion or hoax. Believers understand the problem, but are unwilling to abandon increasingly untenable hypotheses. That’s what results in more and more outlandish attempts to explain the total lack of *real* evidence. I mean really… Does anyone really believe that Bigfoot is an “interdimensional entity?” Some folks claim to believe it, but I find it hard to take them seriously. Perhaps some day some evidence for at least something along these lines will be found. But as the decades pass and still all we have are anecdotes of various degrees of unlikelihood, the chance gets closer and closer to zero.

  • Red Pill Junkie

    I don’t know if I would like to get ‘jiggy’ with Villas Boas’ alien partner, you know? Even though the retold folklore often states that she was voluptuous and fairly easy on the eye, I once read an article written by some Spanish researchers that went down to Brazil and interviewed Antonio’s sister; and she said that according to Antonio, not only the ‘woman’ barked like a dog, she was also UGLY as a dog.

    Picture yourself having sex with a being with the face portrayed in Strieber’s famous Communion book, only that instead of being bald it had blonde hair, and then tell us if you’re still interested in joining the inter-species Connection Club :P

  • Red Pill Junkie

    I don’t know if I would like to get ‘jiggy’ with Villas Boas’ alien partner, you know? Even though the retold folklore often states that she was voluptuous and fairly easy on the eye, I once read an article written by some Spanish researchers that went down to Brazil and interviewed Antonio’s sister; and she said that according to Antonio, not only the ‘woman’ barked like a dog, she was also UGLY as a dog.

    Picture yourself having sex with a being with the face portrayed in Strieber’s famous Communion book, only that instead of being bald it had blonde hair, and then tell us if you’re still interested in joining the inter-species Connection Club :P

  • Red Pill Junkie

    I don’t know it’s fair when we say “there’s no evidence”. Direct evidence is one thing. But even Nick would agree there’s plenty of indirect evidence, both on Ufology and Cryptozoology –whatever these phenomena are, they are able to interact and leave an impression in our landscapes.

    The COMETA report elaborated by European researchers (like Vallee) list many excellent cases where the UFOs left distinct impressions on the soil after they landed, and that also altered the surrounding vegetation. There’s also the radiation burns suffered by many witnesses, like the infamous Cash-Landrum case of 1980. With Bigfoot, we do have some footprints that seem to pass the test of authenticity.

    None of these might be *conclusive* proof. But they constitute evidence that there’s something out there.

  • Red Pill Junkie

    Re. the Simonton case, I never understood why people dismiss it so easily as a hoax, just because when analyzed they didn’t find any unknown components on them.

    People often forget that prior the pancake gift, one of the entities stepped down form the saucer, and through mimic let Simonton know they wanted water. So, if one takes this into account, one could also conclude they might have asked for flour and other ingredients to Simonton’s neighbor the week before! Why bother with carrying all your groceries in your tiny saucer, when you can always go and take them from the friendly locals? ;)

    in fact, I often wonder if this “extra-light” approach of traveling is not being carried out to incredible extremes; let’s say you want to send travelers to a distant world, which is easier and less energy-intensive: sending a massive spaceship that needs to carry food and the travelers and support them for years or centuries through the long distances, OR beaming/transmitting the travelers in energy form, and once in their destination, using some form of self-replicating technology to construct temporary bodies for them? this would also have the nice advantage that the fleshly Avatars are already primed to interact with the alien atmosphere and gravity of the world you wish to explore.

    I’m obviously speculating too… or AM I??  :P

  • Mattjlev

    George P. Hansen has theorized about the elusive nature of paranormal or supernatural phenomena in his book, ‘The Trickster and the Paranormal.’ According to his theory, the reason is cultural. Paranormal phenomena occupy, in Western culture, the role of the Trickster. Thus the paranormal exhibits qualities that the trickster does in other cultures, such as being elusive, untrustworthy, dangerous, etc. Science, as a school of thought, is about binaries; dualities; yes or no, right or wrong. The trickster is liminal; inbetween, blurry, undefinable. This is why science has, as of yet, been unable to comprehend the paranormal. Science tries to place the paranormal into a frame which cannot possibly frame it. Perhaps if we want to truly understand those things we call paranormal, we must look to another school of thought than science.

  • SecretsunCK

    How much proof do the isolated Amazonian tribes have as to the identities of the gods who fly in the big silver birds they see from time to time? As far as hominids go, if they exist they could be very rare and very cagey. We have plenty of plaster casts of footprints- entire branches of science are based around far less evidence. As to abduction, I believe it is very possible these experiences are placed within the mind through some form of hypnosis or kind of technology we can only guess at.

    No serious person can say we have no evidence. It’s totally ridiculous and worse, incredibly myopic. We’re not seeing people like Steven Hawking or Royal Society discuss the issue just to pass the time. There’s all the evidence in the world if you choose to be honest and not throw out what doesn’t conform to your narcissitic solipsism. And who knows what evidence is being withheld- perhaps even proof. The fact is that if we had proof all of this would become as tedious and compartmentalized as all of the officially-approved sciences are.

  • SecretsunCK

    Nick,my response is not directed at you personally, but at the argument which has become a meme unto itself.

  • Raj

    Great stuff, Nick.  You might find this interesting:
    http://amidnightsuns.blogspot.com/2011/06/pulsed-frequencies-physics-and-dna.html

  • Nick_redfern

    Good to see the post has provoked a lot of commentary and debate! I don’t dispute we have (when it comes to Bigfoot) things like plaster-casts of alleged Bigfoot prints, or film and photos.

    And it’s much the same with Ufology: there are photos and film, people have marks on their bodies where they claim they were poked and prodded by aliens.

    But, my main point, is that it seems to be the case that the hard, undeniable, 100 percent proof ALWAYS eludes us, and stays one step ahead of us. I could understand that the UFO phenomenon might be couched in such stealth that for the most part it prevents hard evidence falling into our hands, in the same way I can see that (hypothetically) a small colony of Bigfoot could do likewise.

    But, that’s not what we’re seeing. What we ARE seeing are phenomena that consistently seem to have the ability to avoid providing undeniable evidence of their existence on a 100 percent basis, and with a success-rate unparalleled.

    People might say: “Well, what about the Roswell debris?” I say: “What about it?” The fact is that even the locals, or military personnel on-site who say they xsecretly scooped up some small pieces and kept it can’t present it to us. It’s gone.

    To me, this does not suggest hoaxing. Rather, it suggests a phenomenon that toys with us, that is not what it appears to be, and that (in terms of what the witness sees) may be far more visionary in nature than having any bearing on a literal physical, “real,” 3-D encounter.

  • Pastor Swope

    Nick,  You are onto something with the Tulpas. I have heard of witnesses of the paranormal have a sudden spirt of unexplained encounters in their life. I myself have had a big bird encounter a few times, and the done time I had a camera, the new batteries suddenly died and I missed a close up of the creature. In other creature, UFO and entity encounters I have had, there always is a ethereal calmness in the encounter. Opposite of what I have experienced with hostile entities.

  • Shadowclasper

    not to be a nay sayer >> but honestly, I’m a skeptic at heart about these sorts of things ^^; I’d LOVE to be proven wrong (and adamantly seek to prove myself right in the hopes of being wonderfully surprised) but honestly a lot of these just sound kinda like stories people make up >>; first released stories are more credible to me, things that come later, things that end up with someone “ALMOST” getting something, just feels wrong =S

    Tulpas MIGHT be theoretically possible of course… again, I’d err on the side of “vivid hallucinations” before I went to say they were actually physical >> there are mental disorders and such that can fully simulate the entire sensory spectrum, certainly there should be ways to induce them.

    Again, not saying that it’s IMPOSSIBLE, just that the vast majority of these cases are likely hoaxes… people want a cool story to tell.

    Now, here’ the fundamental problem with trying to prove this phenomenon >> the entire NATURE of the phenomenon is that it makes 100% proof impossible. If such a phenomenon existed, the only way to test it would be to seek out the things that it covers… which you can’t get 100% proof of, which prevents you from even finding out if there’s something that this force IS protecting because you can never -prove- that the force exists >> which makes it about as useless as scientology, creationism, and any other “pseudo-science” that can’t bring hard facts to bear.

    Also, why does this phenomenon protect SOME things and not others? Platupie are pretty damn strange creatures >> so are many cryptids. I find it HARD to believe any technology could manipulate the very laws of chance…

    if it’s a creation of mental constructs, pure will power as it were, then we need to find a way to prove that the human mind is CAPABLE of conjuring what is effectively instant mass and energy that comes from no where and disappears back into the ether… though if this force somehow protects THIS capability then all of a sudden we’ve got a serious problem don’t we?

    I’m not saying that such a thing doesn’t exist. But if something CANNOT be disproved, then it isn’t a valid hypothesis scientifically, and it can’t be TAKEN scientifically seriously (one of the criteria of the scientific method is that a hypothesis MUST be able to be disproven >> this theory doesn’t seem to merit that)

    Though again :3 I will be VERY pleasantly surprised if this force IS discovered. Hell. I’d KILL to be the scientist who discovered such a force :P It’d make me the biggest name in science since Einstein XD (to all of you who claim that my position is closed minded :3)