John Keel: Father of Modern Forteana, or Just Another Guy?

Hands down, when it comes to my favorite investigators of the strange and unusual, two names immediately leap into mind: Jacques Vallee, the computer scientist, ufologist, and author of his famous Alien Contact Trilogy. The other figure that manifests is, of course, that famous explorer and master-journalist of the unexplained, the late John Keel.

In fact, while many following in the footsteps of researcher Charles Fort have adopted for themselves the title of “Forteans,” let it be known here and now that I would personally be as proud to carry the title of “Keelian” in the line of research I do. So let it be written, and verily, so let it be known: “Micah A. Hanks: Keelian Researcher.”

Indeed, it was Keel’s strange ramblings through Point Pleasant, West Virginia, during the late 1960s that resulted in public knowledge of the so-called “Mothman”: that ominous and lingering winged presence of cryptozoological and possibly ultradimensional origin that still haunts many of us to this day. Keel was also heralded as one of the finest examples of modern ufologists in his day, much like his contemporary Vallee; but as is often the bane of many investigators of the unexplained, Keel often found his literary contributions overshadowed by the strange nature surrounding the growing body of his work. Thus, it’s interesting to look back on the man himself, and consider Keel’s own feelings toward the state of ufology during his lifetime, and how seriously he took all of it as the years progressed.

At the John Keel blog (and for any who didn’t know this site existed, it’s a must-see for fellow “Keelians” like myself), I recently discovered this reprint of an obscure interview with Keel, dating back to 1985, which appeared in the Shavertron Magazine. This was a magazine devoted (as the name implies) to the work of Richard Sharp Shaver, who during the late 1940s contributed a multitude of psychotic ramblings in the form of longwinded essays he sent to one Ray Palmer, editor at the Ziff-Davis publication Amazing Stories. Shaver’s strange–albeit unique–interpretation of a race of underground beings that enslaved and manipulated mankind formed the nucleus of what would eventually be Amazing Stories‘ greatest triumph: the so-called “Shaver Mystery.” This entire mythos would later spill over into early ufology, especially after Palmer, who went on to found FATE Magazine in 1947, would begin to draw parallels between Shaver’s wild claims (Palmer accepted these, at least partially, as fact) and the emerging reports of “flying saucers” seen around the same time.

In the interview, which can be viewed here, it’s interesting to note that Keel, by this time somewhat disillusioned with the idea of UFOs and ultra-terrestrials, seems more cynical than anything. Despite this, there are moments of utter clarity that stem from the master, where glimpses of the more important aspects of this field of study become sublimely apparent.

For instance, when Keel is asked about being an authority on UFOs, he replies that, “NOBODY is an authority on UFOs. I expect to be remembered as a novelist and a playwright, if I am remembered at all.” At many points throughout the interview, Keel expresses sentiments such as these, lamenting somewhat the fact that so much of his work outside the realms of the unexplained seems have been overlooked by the UFO audience. Toward the end of the interview, Keel notes that, “I have a couple of books slated to appear in the next year. They have nothing to do with UFOs. It’ll be interesting to see how many UFO fans even realize they exist.”

Fortunately, Keel seemed to be wrong about a few things. When asked about the future of ufology, he retorted that ufology “has no future,” and that it would be “totally dead by 1987, the fortieth anniversary of the Arnold sighting.” This, of course, was not the case: but one thing can certainly be argued: that little, if anything, has changed about the field since the subject was first broached in Arnold’s day. Despite the predictions of Edward J. Ruppelt and the like, who supposed back in the 1950s that the UFO mystery would be solved, “in the next few decades,” this simply hasn’t been the case. Perhaps, as all this pertains to Keel’s rather bleak outlook on the subject in 1985, it’s really a matter of how you define “totally dead.” In my opinion, stagnant may be a more accurate description of what Keel was trying to express. True, though UFO books have continued to be published, the majority of them re-hash the old encounters–and the researchers who investigated those encounters–ad nauseam. Once could easily argue that there has been little growth in the field in the last few decades.

Regardless of what can be discerned about Keel and his feelings from this interview, it provides a fascinating (and sometimes rocky, if not altogether crass) portrait of the author at age 55, and of his perception of the future of this research. Somewhat remarkably, despite the influence his work has had on so many since the publication of books such as The Mothman Prophecies, Keel seemed utterly detached from the stranger things he had written about in his lifetime.

Some might view his disposition as slightly desperate, or merely disenchanted. Others might see Keel as having lacked faith in the body of his own work… but there is also a zen-like sense of “no-mindedness” which could be perceived from this: a man who, while a master of his craft, was all-too careful about giving himself to it entirely. Some might call him a master of Forteana, while I, on the other hand, would prefer to rectify the “Keelian” title in his honor. Keel himself on the other hand, looking back on all this posthumously, might be every bit as happy considering himself “just another guy”: another wanderer who, while inconsequential in the grand scheme of things, sought answers in his lifetime to something he couldn’t reconcile with entirely.

A wanderer perhaps… but evoking the immortal words of Tolkien, “not all who wander are lost.” This, we can say with utter certainty, was very much the case with Mr. John Alva Keel.

Tags

Micah Hanks is a writer, podcaster, and researcher whose interests cover a variety of subjects. His areas of focus include history, science, philosophy, current events, cultural studies, technology, unexplained phenomena, and ways the future of humankind may be influenced by science and innovation in the coming decades. In addition to writing, Micah hosts the Middle Theory and Gralien Report podcasts.
You can follow Micah on and