Nov 17, 2026 I Julian Vale

Before Point Pleasant Had a Name for It

At the abandoned power plant north of Point Pleasant, the first thing that made sense was the height. Whatever stood there was about as tall as a man. The rest of it was harder to place. Roger and Linda Scarberry and Steve and Mary Mallette described large red eyes and wings folded against a grey body. They left in the car, only to see the figure again near the road. This time it spread its wings and rose.

It was the night of 15 November 1966. The four had driven into the old munitions grounds that people around Point Pleasant called the TNT area. Now, on the road back to town, they said the creature was keeping up with them. Their estimate put the car at about a hundred miles an hour. They remembered the thing gliding. By the time they reached Point Pleasant, it had peeled away, leaving them with the problem of how to describe what they had seen.

The next day the Point Pleasant Register tried several words in a single headline: “Couples See Man-Sized Bird…Creature…Something.” Steve Mallette gave the paper the image he kept coming back to: “It was like a man with wings.” Sixty years later, that sentence is still worth sitting with. We have grown so accustomed to calling the thing Mothman that the name can arrive in our minds before the figure has even moved. The people in the car had to make sense of it in the opposite order.

Along the back of the car

In the early accounts gathered by investigators, the creature’s movement on the ground was awkward. In the air it was another matter. Roger described it rising straight up and then gliding. Mary recalled a high, peculiar sound and compared it to a recording played too fast. Their impressions give the pursuit an odd change of pace: a thing ungainly enough to be noticed on foot could suddenly follow a moving car without struggling to keep up.

There is a drawing attributed to Roger Scarberry among the papers of John Keel, the writer who would later investigate the encounters. The surviving copy is a useful companion to the written account. A witness asked to draw a thing has to decide where one part ends and another begins. In this instance the assignment was particularly strange. A person who has just been trying to get away from something must now work out how to put its body down on paper.

Mary Hyre was reporting for Ohio’s Athens Messenger from Point Pleasant. Her first story went straight to the chase: the height, the red eyes and the figure that seemed able to travel beside a speeding car. In the same issue, readers could find a short item about the Leonid meteor shower. One story told people when to look up. The other gave them a place to drive after dark, with no assurance about what might be waiting there.

Drivers did go looking. Hyre later described traffic bunching up on the roads through the former plant grounds. There is a peculiarity to that first wave of interest that a later festival can only partly recover. A reader could hear the story in town, go home for the car and travel the same road before the people who told it had put a week between themselves and the encounter. The setting was still familiar enough to visit and had just become difficult to see in the old way.

Something rose beside the parked car

For Marcella Bennett, the encounter came much nearer to home. On the evening of 16 November, she had gone to visit relatives in the TNT area with her young daughter and members of her family. They were leaving the Thomas house when she approached the parked car carrying her child. In her later account, something stood up behind the vehicle. She first noticed its legs. The figure was tall, with grey plumage or a featherlike covering, its wings drawn close and its head held low against the shoulders.

Bennett fell trying to get back to the house. She picked up her daughter and made it inside, where the family locked the door and called the sheriff’s department. The account has the creature coming onto the porch before it went away. The yard was searched after officers arrived. By then the thing that had sent the family indoors was gone.

The Bennett story brings the encounter within reach of a house key. On the first night, the car had been a way out, a means of putting distance between the witnesses and a figure on the road. On the second, the parked car was the thing obscuring the figure until Bennett was close. Once the family was inside, there was a door between them and the yard. They could call for help, but opening it would mean looking again.

A grey figure with folded wings rises behind a parked car outside a house at night

The newspapers were already trying to name what people were seeing. Hyre’s follow-up ran as “Monster Returns to Mason.” On 17 November the Huntington Herald-Dispatch used “Moth Man” in a headline about people hunting the creature. The name appeared within days, alongside the more ordinary word bird. A name made it easier to ask whether there had been another sighting. It could also make a new account sound more familiar than it felt to the person giving it.

After sunrise

Tom Ury brought the story into daylight. In Hyre’s reporting, the 25-year-old from Clarksburg was driving along Route 62 at about 7:15 on a Friday morning later in November. Near the Homer Smith farm, roughly eight miles north of Point Pleasant, he said he saw a figure rise from a field. The comparison he reached for was a helicopter.

That is an interesting thing for a witness to say about something the papers were calling a bird. A helicopter can lift almost straight up, with little suggestion of a run or a leap. Roger Scarberry had also described a vertical rise. The two accounts give that movement different surroundings: a dark road and a car trying to get away, then a field visible in the morning. The daylight story makes the strange ascent easier to picture and harder to forget.

A winged silhouette lifts from a field beside a West Virginia road in early daylight

By then, other people were supplying their own images of the creature. A painting by Point Pleasant’s Jack Park appeared in the Messenger on 2 December, based on published descriptions. Put a sighting into a drawing and readers can compare it with the picture they have already formed. Give the figure a name as well, and it can travel from person to person without anyone having to start with the troublesome question of what shape it was.

Before it became an omen

Hyre went on covering strange reports and worked with Keel as he investigated the area. She was also the local correspondent who had to write about the collapse of the Silver Bridge on 15 December 1967, when 46 people died. Keel’s The Mothman Prophecies later brought the encounters and the disaster into the same enduring story. Returning to that first November gives the witnesses back an earlier moment, when no one in the car could have known how much later history would gather around their drive.

In 2026, Ohio State’s Center for Folklore Studies and Humanities Institute are marking the anniversary with a series called Moth-Vember. The programme includes a screening of the 2002 film and a talk about how American monsters take shape in the telling. There is something fitting about the anniversary being marked across the river in Ohio, where Hyre’s paper carried the story so early. The creature left Point Pleasant in print almost as soon as it arrived.

The first witnesses were still close enough to the experience to talk about particular things: the eyes, the awkward movement and the sudden lift. Bennett could describe how near she had got to the car before she saw what was beside it. Ury offered the image of a helicopter because that was how the ascent had struck him. These are small acts of recognition within encounters that resisted recognition as a whole. Together, they recover some of the unease that gets lost when a creature is familiar enough to have a statue.

The Scarberry sketch and the newspaper headline ask the reader to picture the same encounter in different ways. The headline gives the figure two familiar outlines to choose from. The sketch lets them coexist, with the wings rising around the body and the eyes set low between them. A reporter had to get an unfamiliar shape into a few words. A witness with a pencil could leave the shape just as strange as he remembered it. That drawing is worth looking at before looking at the statue. Its proportions belong to an account given before anyone knew what a Mothman was supposed to look like.

Read those accounts in the order they reached the papers and something of those first days comes back. A car turns towards town. A family gets behind a locked door. In daylight, a driver sees something leave a field. The name is already beginning to catch on. The people who saw the thing are still trying to find words for it.

Further Reading

For reports that take the mystery beyond Point Pleasant, listen to 30.08, Mothman Raids Again. Join Mysterious Universe Plus+ at the Max tier to stream the episode and explore the available back catalogue.

Julian Vale

Julian Vale writes about strange encounters, unexplained events and the mysteries of remote places. His features bring together eyewitness accounts and overlooked stories, following the connections between experiences separated by time and geography.

Previous article

Someone in the Mirror Room

Join MU Plus+ and get exclusive shows and extensions & much more! Subscribe Today!

Search: